Even though the Mariners were winning most of the game, it still felt like they were going to have to win on a comeback, which they eventually did.
The Yankees were dominating the ABS challenge system, and the Mariners had a few defensive miscues, driving all the focus to the Yankees’ half-innings. Meanwhile, despite putting up a run in the second inning, the Mariners bats had mostly gone down quickly and quietly. So as we reached the midpoint, this was one of those games where it was easy to forget that the Mariners were winning.
Advertisement
But winning they were because that second-inning run was enough to hold the lead throughout Luis Castillo’s six innings of work. La Piedra came out firing for his first start of the season, hitting 96.5 mph with his fastball, something he only topped four times before May last year. He left one a little too close to middle-middle against Aaron Judge for my comfort, but he got away with it and eventually jammed him on a sinker running all the way in on his hands. You might chalk the velo spike up to first-game adrenaline, but he held it for most of his outing. With his fastball unhittable, why would he go to anything else? Well, because his slider was as about as sharp as it gets. So the first time through the order, he only threw one pitch that was anything but a four-seamer or slider—the sinker that finished off Judge.
Of course, Yankees were still reaching base. Twice, a can of corn dropped in shallow left: the first time due to an early-season miscommunication, and the second time because both Donovan and Rivas lost the ball in the lights. And for as well as Castillo was pitching, the Yankees were all over Mike Estabrook’s mistakes behind the plate, successfully challenging five calls in the fourth inning alone.
But overall, Castillo was too sharp to be beat. He surrendered just two “hits”: one on the lost-in-the-lights pop-up and the other a weakly hit groundball that Castillo himself couldn’t quite handle. But his seven strikeouts were all well earned. The most visually pleasing was when Cody Bellinger couldn’t come within a foot of either a backfoot slider or a fastball up out of the zone. But the most notable was Castillo’s final punchout of the night, the 1,500th of his career.
It didn’t have to be a strikeout. It started off on one of his worst pitches of the game—a slider left right over the heart of the plate. But just like he did in his first-inning face-off with Judge, Castillo got away with it. “[Judge] looked at me and smiled,” Castillo said after the game. He says the two of them have admired each other from a distance, leading to something like a friendship from afar. “But I think if I threw that pitch again, there’s no way he’s not going to swing, there’s no way I get to strikeout 1,500.”
Advertisement
Fortunately, he proceeded to throw three better sliders, the final one of which might have hit Judge if he hadn’t swung at it. Castillo laughed about that final pitch with his teammates in the dugout watching on the iPad afterwards. “I was looking at the movement of the pitch. It was so weird. It was moving like, I don’t know, like a splitter-slash-changeup? Like I don’t think I’ve ever thrown a pitch like that in my life. It’s nothing like the slider I throw.” For being both weird and contributing to a milestone, that pitch also earns Luis Castillo tonight’s Sun Hat Award, an honor I give out in my recaps to the player who made a notable individual contribution to the game.
View Link
That completes the Mariners’ first turn through the rotation for 2026, in which the five starters put up a combined 29.1 innings with 38 strikeouts to six walks, 13 hits, and six runs. After a down year last year, the early returns from the rotation suggest it will once again be one of Seattle’s strengths.
Castillo left with the lead thanks to a second-inning sequence in which Randy Arozarena led off with a single, Mitch Garver moved him to second by turning an 0-2 count into a 10-pitch walk, and Cole Young batted him in with his first of three hits on the night. But as soon as Castillo departed, the Yankees were able to tie it at 1-1 because while Jose Ferrer got the three ground balls you hope for, he couldn’t turn them into outs.
Advertisement
But while the Mariners left two runners on in each of the fifth and seventh, the fact that they were getting baserunners and that Gabe Speier and Matt Brash had dominant outings gave you the sense that the Mariners bats would eventually pull this one out. Letting Gabe Speier pitch to Aaron Judge was an inspired choice, speaking to the well-founded confidence the team has in him to face righties. Technically, Judge won the battle with a hit, but I’m still giving Speier the victory since it was on a 79-mph ground ball. Brash finished his inning with the nastiest slider of the season (so far) to get revenge on Amed Rosario for his earlier game-tying RBI.
Still, despite the rising feeling that a walk-off was imminent, when Leo Rivas and Brendan Donovan reached the corners to open the ninth, it brought up the ice-cold heart of the Mariners order, and suddenly it wasn’t such a foregone conclusion that the Mariners would win.
For his part, Cal Raleigh is dismissive of the cold start. “A lot of people across the league are fighting the same thing. Guys are trying to find their timing. And it’s more under a microscope, more so now than it is in the middle of a season, just because it’s the start of the season, everybody’s excited, they can keep up with certain numbers.”
He says he feels fine in the box. And tonight he was able to execute, sending a decent Paul Blackburn cutter down the right field line for the Mariners’ first walk-off win of the year. “It’ll be OK,” he said. “I think everybody’s going to be just fine.”
View Link
Read the full article here
